general

NCR is the best written faction in the series imo

Well when I think of a good use and realistic use of groups/towns

I think of Junktown

Look, I only know so much of old fallout

In NV, 3 and 4. All the factions feel more like charicutres of factions

to a degree

New Vegas?

Yeah even NV

its not as bad as 3 and 4

3 I'd agree on, and 4 for the most part

Big one incoming

A really megaton of info

but I mean the boomers represent just some simple concept, the chairmen are just one simple concept, white glove, gomorroah, the BoS just is a singular concept (granted theyve always represented these concepts, but they used to be more trident like with what they were). While theyre more indepth in NV than 3 and 4 I still feel theyre not done great

I get too that they commented that factions weren't as done as theyd like

which is fair

The Great Khans ironically are probably better done than most of the minor factions of NV due to this

for major factions Ceasers Legion is half baked goods and without the other side of the river and content to reinforce them- they come off as larping joke with a big brained leader destined to fail.

What do you mean just a concept? The three families are meant to be fairly "simplified" because Mr House had them abandon their tribal ways

You don't get much history on them by design, they all formed really recently

I agree on the boomers though

Yeah but even then you don't really see a resurgance of those except in the white glove society (which makes them the best of them tbf) but even that is a shortish quest thats two quests that are convoluted in many ways and poorly done.

The chairmen really got the short end of the stick

The Gomorrah are just "Hey crime boss shady dealings 😎 "

Like

If they all had a resurgence of their old tribal ways it would seem repetitive. I'd pick the omertas as the most interesting of the 3 tbh because of how deep the rabbit hole goes in their questlines

As far as tribal history goes this tells you all that you need to know

yooo

You guys like fallout?

We have to argue this because max won't take my bait saying the frieza saga is shit

An example I guess you can see in the BoS in a way. In fallout 1 you have 4 major characters in the BoS who all represent major parts of the BoS, the Paladin who represents the militaristic side all order and tactics war and etc., the head scribe who represents the intelligence the research of technologies and the creation of new ones. cabbot just an initate who is enthusastic of the world and little knowledge of it partially due to the shelteredness of the BoS but also him being just an initiate, and the elder who draws from all three and that shows the brotherhood is a mixture not a singular archetype. In NV you have Ramos who barely represents anything. You have a paladin who doesnt like the current elder so he angry. The scribes are essentially non-existent NPCs. Most of the good parts are lent to the insanity and depravity of the elders, Veronica is just a dyke and same with Christine except Christine is angwy. The faction is simple as what the wasteland sees them as "A bunch of crazy tech people with issues."

If they all had a resurgence of their old tribal ways it would seem repetitive.

I didnt mean resurgence but hints, or anything to deepen their character archetypes. The Chairmen really suffer from this and Benny doesn't really carry them at all because he feels like his own party. I can write a lot about the different factions and their goals and why they can/do exist, why they turned out the way they did, the people attracted to it, the people they make for fallout 1/2 (not all of them though) For NV it's a lot harder. As you said, and I agree, the NCR does that part well, the rest I think I'd disagree on.

I still think NV does factions great, but they are a lot more simplified and more one note like 3 and 4

A quasi-religious militaristic technocracy

the most unreasonable faction though is still the minutemen

But aren't you getting a few members? I remember there was the excitable teen girl that almost got herself and her partner killed on a mission and Hardin of course

His reason for disliking the elder is the lockdown is stressful so he wants to demote the elder to scribe or iniatete and become elder

Fine, but to say he's "just angry" when his goal is to usurp the brotherhood and return to attacking technological hotspots in the wasteland is really simplifying things

His stated goal is just to regain resources iirc

I think the Followers also

slightly suffer from this

Essentailly yes but I found them more interesting than the Mojave version

Going back to the BoS, in fallout 1 they were the major player in their region so of course they'd get relatively more development. But when you say they have 4 big characters of interest that sounds about equal to NV

The point is more

their characters help show and develop what the faction is and what it represents

you get a lot less of that in NV

Because everyone except veronica is packed into a bunker

Scribes being nonexistent essentially is proof of that

the four major characters are all in the bunker

well cabbot is at the door

your only interaction with the scribes is ooo smarty pants weird virus minigame

and i think the elder gets demoted to scribe

or its initate i forgot

I vaguely remember that

Also, veronica is called a scribe apparently

But she's not a character because she's lesbo

yeah but she doesnt act like one

thats sorta her char

she doesnt fit anything

suppoused to be girl but is dyke BoS but wants a dress Scribe but asks hardin to learn how to box

her entire character is not being BoS but she still treats them as family

again more was most defnitely planned for all the factions

but time crunch

I think they did just fine with it

I honestly think BoS is fine and I am fine with it but I still think they're done a certain way

They're the reason why I'm iffy with house's ending

The only factions I really want more of are the Great Khans and Powder Gangers. They probably got the most content out of the minor factions but they should of been expanded more.

The powder gangers?

I think their questline is anti climatic

and making the vault 19? powder ganger quest seperate was also a bad idea

They're a bunch of mostly destructive criminals that have a few reluctant members that joined the herd during the jailbreak

They felt pretty disposable

The two big powder ganger questlines are entirely unreleated and you can EASILY miss the vault one

You can also easily miss all of their quests just by doing the tutorial

Yeah, that part is dumb

I wonder how many players know you can get some of them to join the great khans

What makes you think the khans are done better than the rest

They seem very comparable to the brotherhood in that they have a couple notable quests, but are defined by their disastrous history in the mojave

I think its more what you can do with their questline and you atleast can see different faucets

you have the drug running sect you have the brutal initiation and the problems it brings bitter springs and their relations to the NCR causing problems and effects with the leader (similar to BoS) ceasers influence on the tribe and the effects of bringing them in, telling them to suicide at the damn for history, or telling them to inact in a quest similar to Genghis khan and forge their own history