games

awesome incredible

Both games had too much busy work with no payoff

tarrytown had actual payoff

not a single quest in totk

has payoff

there's no long quest chain that rewards you

I liked fixing the beach town

you get three free shitty monster parts per

like week

wower

I don't even do that, I just like that you got to fix a town

tarrytown gives you better arrow prices better selling prices a way to get the hylian shield again etc.

I never used tarrytown for any of that either. I also just liked the idea of making a town

i take it as rhe same concept as other long quest chains biggoron, ww trade etc.

you get a reward equal to the effort you put in

totk has nothing

collecting five hundred shitty bubble gems to get a usless armor set

isn't a reward or fun

I was super excited at first because I thought all those hyrule reconstruction society stands were going to be like Tarrytown

the bubble gems was "what if we did korroks again, but also did korroks a different way"

and if you build something, NPCs people start using them or smt

i unironically found

finding the wells for the well slut npc

to be more fun

yes

because it's novel

I thought the frogs were fun, before it became a quest chain

but the wells were just fun

instead of oh where the bubbul frog in this cave

this cave has nothing of note

but you know

OH

and the fucking

newspaper questline

actual dogshit

you get N O T H I N.G

never started that I guess

lol

for like 10 hours

you have to visit every stable in Hyrule

for NOTHING

quests were a big let down

botw didn't have a ton of great ones, because it was sandbox-first

and somehow totk was a step down

i also don't know how they fucked up the no inventory stuff

Maybe I enjoyed the game more by not doing any story at all for like 50 hours and just walking around

evertidr and trial of the mastersword are some of the most fun in any zelda game

totk has shrines where you get no items sure

but it misses the entire point

I disagree with those being the most fun in any zelda game

they were okay

of using resources you build up over a point of time

instead it's just fight with a stick

master sword trial on master mode is unironically the best combat a zelda game has ever had

it's exhilarating

who the fuck plays zelda for combat though

botw and towk are probably about equal imo, but botw by virtue of being first and nostalgia feels better

appearently enough people for them to make entire dlc about it

because that dlc is incredible

and most people think botw and totk are the best zelda games ever made, so I guess we are just weird

I think botw is top 3 for me

bad zelda games good game (botw) mid game (totk)

I’ve only played botw so it’s my favorite zelda game

:)

YES!!!

the whole "bad zelda game" thing just seems dumb to me

SOMEONE BESIDES ME SAID IT

LETS GO!!!

you can reskin all of botw to another game and it wouldn't change

I get what it means, and I agree

its a good game

it's just nothing like loz

Ror2 is a bad ror game

it just seems like a dumb statement to preface all discussion of botw with

ror2 is actually the perfect port of ror to 3d

i think it's a fair statement

I don't think thats a fair comparison

because it's nothing like zelda

But pika if you reskinned it and ror2 never existed you wouldn’t say this is ror