anime

one of my favourite episodes in 86 is basically anime original, with only like 1 line being from the ln

The best episode in shippuden is filler

I understand your point but I disagree

I forget are you a marvel fan vinny

Half assedly

so you hate the new spidermen movies right

I like Tom Holland as the character but the movies themselves are just ok

they are all not based on any source comic and infact, go counter to the character of spiderman

(or so I have heard)

(from nerds who really care)

actually most marvel movies are like that

I think its just silly that I cannot sit down, watch spiderman, and judge if it is a good film or not

The mcu pulls from several versions of the characters making them their own version

Are you skipping the filler parts of one piece

since they do not matter

Most likely

alright, we clearly do not share any semblance of similarity when it comes to what it means to watch something

lol

I'm considering not skipping exclusively to say on the vlog I watched all of it

But really filler is meh to me

I am trying to gauge your position here on how you can hold something against a show when it is not apart of the source

so, fullmetal alchemist for example, can we not conclude that by your metric, the original and brotherhood are the same quality, since we ignore the anime original parts of the original

when making judgements

I don't hold things against an adaptation if it is not part of what is being adapted

same quality maybe minus things like animation quality

and what not

as a story, they are completely equal

Like the parts of '03 that are adapted in a lot of places stand above brotherhood

Cause they got lazy and assumed you watched '03 so they truncated it

so the show as a whole then, is better than brotherhood

since we ignore the anime original parts of the original

when judging it

Taking just the adapted parts into consideration brotherhood is better overall because it's a complete adaptation

This isn't to say I didn't enjoy '03, but as an adaptation brotherhood is better in my eyes

okay, its a better adapatation

but that says nothing about its quality as a show

I don't care about the source at all

I think you can point to parts of a show, talk about what you like/don't like about them, and conclude if they are good, without even needing to know the source material

So excluding parts of the show from judgement arbitrarily because some other media did not include them

is silly

The only example I can give is index since I am reading the ln for that. I think a lot of the arcs in index 1 are bad adaptations

they completely change what happens

I also think that the changes are for the better

and the ln is worse in those parts

It's not arbitrary though, due to it being an adaptation of someone else's work

but it is also its own work

it is using a base story

but there is always changes

and you can judge the thing that is adapted without considering the original

at all