autism

and can make them better

if done well of course

i dont think

I think a well done panel can add more

than some nice sound

big disagree

I disagree greatly

as someone

you guys are comparing wildly different things

who has read tons of manga and watched anime for years

I really think a S+ manga can beat a S+ anime

it's the same problem I have with people who dismiss Vinland Saga, by posting manga panels

Max different people have different tastes

no shit, single still pages will be better than anime stills

yeah rusp no shit

We shit on DEEN for taking it too far sometimes but there is something gained in animation

people have different tastes

the thing is max, you always say everything as if it is objective fact

and it triggers people

okay

let me add

"I think"

to every single sentance

Fire found the issue

There is something about the complete package being done right that is so much more satisfying to me is all

*I think, Fire found the issue

pika as somone who mainly watches comedy

what the fuck

are you talking about

POG

I do not mainly watch comedy

I think

i feel like this is wrong

the shit I watch is all over the place, because I base what I watch purely off of youtube recommending me random clips

The thing is max, you can't have it both ways

You can't say you're a girl but also claim to be correct on everything

pika most of your top is

action of comedy

a like 60/40 split

What can anime do to be good then Max? is it a problem of visuals, or a problem of the single cour format?

I'm not saying all anime is bad

i havent said that

no, you are saying there is some aspect of anime that is less good then manga

I think adaptations are the problem

I know, but given that you don't watch much season-to-season

and we want to know what that is

it's clear you don't enjoy it like you maybe used to

Anime is s l o w, I don't think music adds as much as it should as most anime use filler soundtracks and when they do use good soundtracks its very very rare. You'll never have great looking stills, or if you do other stuff lacks. You can have a manga that is "all good" but you can't have an anime, unless it's a movie that's all good.

Only thing animes can do better is fight scenes and the like because they're well, animated.

I think there is more that can be fucked up when doing an anime because it has more components

A lot more can be fucked up, and it usually is because BUDGET

which is why less anime can be considered great whereas manga has less overall components to handle

The slow part is the only thing I'll agree on, but I do think shows have been getting better, I go to 1.1x or 1.2x less often now

I say this but

Beastars despite being CGI (therefore low quality) and that OP lmao

was one of the best, if not the best for a while i've seen

and its music added so much to it

so soundtracks can be good and add a lot to an anime

I just don't t hink it's ever done well

that is where I am getting at

if done well, it adds a lot

it just is often not done well

Yet, I still like the manga more.

Character driven shows, gain a lot out of being animated. Comedy, SoL, and dramas especially

Which comes into my other thing that, adaptations make anime worse.

Everyone get on the Bus

Max is taking us to Mayoiga

I actually hate watching SoL and comedy anime, after a while I did anyways.

but I'm 100% fine with reading their manga

Slowness is big on that for me

How fast do you read max

because holy fuck SoL is slow

I imagine the fact that you can get through it faster is a part of why you prefer the medium more

I read at an above average speed but

I do take in panels BGs and etc.

I find there are more series that I like, regardless of medium than there are times where I'll harp on "the anime is better" or "the novel is better"

Also as a note, I feel like part of this opinion is more on current era anime

that's more lazy as a whole

Yeah there does seem to be less shows nowadays they give you the complete package with high quality