nintendo

we rewatched them all

You did horribly

what do you strongly disagree with

it was not based on the character at all, but on how cool the trailer was

I disagree with pretty much everything

I can’t exactly go into specifics

How do you not like the ones we put in S

Those are all quality trailers

Palutenas was mid

Banjo I agree with

he just said fighting words

Joker is f tier

Because who cares

it was a cool reveal at the game awards

We had criteria so we could rate them objectively

I art thou

You are wrong

Thou art I

the end of persona is cringe

rating on my end was based on everything before that

Persona as a whole is cringe

Auto f tier

Same with xenoblade

Wtf Rusp don’t say that so flagrantly

again, we did not consider what the character was

when judging the trailers

sora would be bottom of D

if that was the case

Interacted with other characters, had an art style that represented it's series, and gave fans of the series hype before non fans

That’s retarded criteria

Joker was unique because we didn't know it was smash at the beginning

it was not a character tierlist

What’s the point at all

It was a ranking of how good we thought the trailers/announcement videos were

which we only did because the topic of how fun the smash announcement trailers was came up

and we wanted to rewatch them

Vinny will ban you from his chat!

Even with this criteria I still think these are weird rankings

Palutena's was great because it referenced the kid icarus 3DS anime, brought in another character to interact with, and had a cool after credits

You are all wrong I am right

We get it, you hate anime

Correct

little mac was the only good trailer

because it was more of a comic book stetch style

I don’t really get the interacted with other characters thing

thats the fun part of smash

That doesn’t make a trailer more hype

seeing franchises interact

what's the point of smash if you arent crossing over

Sephiroth’s was really funny

I think the point is that they are in the crossover game

Not that link appears for 5 seconds

Yeah, so its neat to see luigi doing ghost hunting in the castlevania castle

I don’t think crossover needs to happen at all in a trailer for it to be good

no, but it adds to it

Especially if it’s a big surprise

the ryu trailer was literally just "hey its ryu" with no build up

and nothing else

steve should be s tier

He’s right

the first part of the steve trailer was just fighting

Hey You, Ryu!

and not exciting

why is that a problem though

I don’t get your ratings at all

Steve's trailer is kind of boring

make your own tier list

it's about the design and composition

mario is sent into the distinctive minecraft cave and the sheer magnitude of steve as he approaches really makes you feel the weight of what just happened

And then

Creeper

aw man

yes, that would be cinema

I think a lot of the big characters bring more hype than a lot of the boring ones ever could

Even with fun trailers

Like the fire emblem ones

Who cares

again, we ignored who the characters were

The tier list is specifically for the trailers though