Since I did it in DMs with polu, here is my half season ranking of what I am watching
anime
Tuesday, May 14, 2024
I am 2 episodes behind, it is kind of a nothing show
To be clear, I like everything I am watching
it is just one of the worst things I am watching
End of season, I expect MHA to piss me off and fall to the bottom
same with demon slayer
my top 3 is likely going to stay in that order
Konosuba makes me hard laugh every episode
I will defend season 1, the movie, and mostly S2
S3 was not the best
I think S1 and the movie in particular are great, S2 is visually stunning during the final fight
Demon slayer has the normal shonen problem of "it gets worse as it goes"
This season is literally a between arcs training arc, and only that, so I do not expect this season to do anything
My problem, Dialga, is I just want some gacha game to get the princess connect treatment
you do not need to give a shit about the gacha for that anime to be great
I think honestly, thats the only one (FGO kind of, but instead of giving a shit about the gacha you just need to like fate)
Princess connect having the director of Konosuba and really over the top good animation is something all of the gachas should do
(not nessisarily the director of konosuba part, but get someone competent)
Replying to Polar_ #polar_ I know Fate opted to skip its first few chapters for its anime, and I don't blame them.
They adapt I think the second last part of the main story lol
Polar, if you like konosuba, watch princess connect
Replying to Polar_ #polar_ Yea they adapted Camalot as a movie, Solomon is a stage play I think aswell, and then Babylonia is the anime. Strange choices.
Opposite order
Babylonia, then Camalot, then Solomon
If you want me to rate those since I watched all of fate, Babylonia is good but needed 3-4 more episodes for better pacing
the Camalot movies kind of sucked but had good parts
Solomon was bad
I am trying to find a tiermaker that has the correct updated list of fate animes
I think I found one? Anyways its scalled to fate so S is just best of fate, F is worst of fate when I post this
Okay this one does not have any of the fucking FGO movies
the thing in D was the post story of FGO which they released an OVA for
the FGO in A is first order, which I forgot to list, which was actually a pretty good movie
I would put the Camelot movies in C at the bottom, and the Solomon movie at the top of D
The only thing that I differ from most people is I liked UBW more than Zero
I liked both a lot though
Illya is the definition of "this is just okay"
I gave every single season a 7
I am missing the illya prequel movie
thats top of A tier
the illya prequel movie was really good
most people do
I liked it
I am the actual opposite of a source purist
so things not following the source is a nonissue for me
Oh, I forgot to rank the UBW deen movie as well
bottom of C
The only fate I think is actively bad to the point where I get mad about it is fate extra, half of the FGO shit, and half of the KnK movies (counting those as fate since shared universe)
Everything else ranges from just okay to I like it
Its a full show not an OVA